This is a blog I wrote to mark Bipolar Awareness Day for the excellent website Black Dog Tribe, where anybody affected by mental illness can find great information from experts as well as a very helpful forum where you can exchange stories and find support
blackdogtribe.com
You can also follow them on Twitter @FollowBDT
Diagnosing somebody
under the blanket term of depression and handing them a pill is like shooting
in the dark and hoping the bullet will find its target.
Which is why, every
time I read about depression in the media or hear that somebody has just been
diagnosed by their GP as having depression, I think, well, what form of
depression? Oh, you know; depression.
Yes, but what … oh, never mind.
But, really, it does matter.
Depression is not a singular illness but a complex set of disorders. Is it
mild, moderate or severe? Is it reactive or chronic? Reactive depression - or a
reaction to a difficult life event might be regarded as a healthy response. It
is only when that depression becomes embedded and morphs into clinical
depression that it becomes part of pathology. Is it Bipolar I? Bipolar II?
Could it be defined as dysthymia, rapid mood cycling or cyclothymia?
That one word,
depression, covers a world of pain and misunderstanding - not simply amongst
the general public but among sufferers themselves. More worryingly, it leads to
misdiagnosis and, sometimes, death.
I don’t mean to sound
alarmist but in my own experience (and it is only my experience because depression is always subjective; no two
cases are the same) it took me ten years, fourteen different medications and
two suicide attempts to get the right diagnosis, which is Bipolar II - or what
my psychiatrist refers to as rapid mood cycling because he is cautious about
stamping labels on people’s foreheads.
Before I found him (and
it was a long search) I was variously diagnosed with major depressive disorder,
clinical depression (although I’ve never actually figured out what that means
other than needing the services of a clinician and medication) resistant
depression and agitated depression.
Medication made my
condition worse, hence the constant battle to find the right combination, or
the bullet that would hit the target. That bullet, in my case, is a combination
of mood stabilisers, antidepressants and sleeping pills. For me, just one night
of insomnia, from which I have suffered since I was a very young child, can
kick-start an episode.
At the time, I had no
idea that SSRIs can make depression worse if you have a bipolar diagnosis
because it exacerbates mood swings. Nor did it occur to me that I might be
bipolar. I was just depressed -majorly
depressed, suicidally depressed, hopelessly depressed, chronically depressed
and with an extremely poor prognosis of ever being well again. The episode that
really kicked me into meltdown lasted for four years which, as anyone who has ever
suffered from severe depression will know is a hell (literally) of a long time.
When I had a breakdown
twelve years ago (I have suffered from depression since my teens but it went
unchecked until I hit an episode so bad, I couldn’t get up again and was
hospitalised three times) my psychiatrist asked me if I thought I might be
bipolar – which is a bit like asking a horse if they might be a donkey. How the
hell are they supposed to know? I said no, purely on the grounds that I
understood bipolar as thinking you were Jesus Christ one minute, then one of
his suffering followers the next.
Then, after two
therapists asked me if I was sure I wasn’t bipolar and, because I am a
journalist and a natural snoop, I began to research bipolar and discovered a
spectrum that includes mania, but not mania as I understood it. My form of
mania is an agitated restlessness, heightened sensitivity to noise (show me a
crisp packet and I have to leave the room), irritability, distorted and
disproportionate responses to simple events and delusional thinking followed by
a headlong fall into black despair. No
mention of Jesus Christ, just the devil in the detail. Rapid mood cycling or
cyclothermia also carries a heightened risk of suicide – with which I am all
too horribly familiar.
I referred myself to a
private psychiatrist (after a great deal more research) because I had
experienced such bruising encounters with NHS psychiatrists - who seemed to
understand less about my illness than I did. Of course, they are not all bad,
and perhaps I was just unlucky, but when it comes to my mental health, I play
no games with Lady Luck. And nor do I mind spending money - a pair of
Loubotins, a Mulberry handbag; or an hour with an expert?
That psychiatrist took
one look at my symptoms, diagnosed rapid mood cycling and wrote out a script
for mood stabilisers along with a cocktail of other drugs which keep me stable;
or as stable as you can expect from a chronic, episodic illness.
It cost me £300 for an
hour’s assessment, but all my drugs are on NHS prescription and I see my
psychiatrist once every six months for a half hour MOT which, as far as I am
concerned is £150 well spent. I know, I’m lucky enough to be able to afford it,
but it is a luxury I would happily save up for, forgoing holidays, a new
television, or a new anything, just to stay well. I can also email him (for
free) if I hit a bad patch and consult him about rebalancing my medication.
Some GPs are great, but
they are not experts in psychopharmacology and nor do they have time to swat up
on the latest research. I would never, these days, go to a GP for a diagnosis
because the inevitable analysis is depression.
Well, yes, but what form?
That has been my experience too. My heart goes out to all of those who are not receiving the right treatment for bipolar II depression. SSRIs made me have mixed states and more suicidal.
ReplyDeleteReceiving the right diagnosis also means I am in the best place to support my children if they ever experience the condition, due to it's genetic link.
Hi Sally. How strange... I just finished Shoot the Damn Dog, and, when I was reading it, I wondered if anyone had ever considered Bipolar as a diagnosis for you, as it seemed to me (a fairly newly diagnosed Bipolar II rapid cycler) that the agitation etc you suffered may have been more indicative of some kind of cycling mood disorder than straight depression. Then I google you, and this is the first result that comes up! I'm glad, at any rate, that they finally caught it. I heard a statistic that it takes on average 10 years to diagnose Bipolar. For me it took 16 years - from my first diagnosis of major depression, aged 16, through subsequent diagnoses of depression, anxiety, and Borderline Personality Disorder. I think the problem that mental health professionals have is that few people present with hypomania. Mania, sure, which is why Bipolar I is an easier diagnosis, with its attendant psychosis, delusions etc. Mania usually requires hospitalisation. But hypomania, although it can still be awfully damaging, can be dismissed or passed off as any number of things, none of which you would tend to report to a doctor (especially hypersexuality, euphoria, impulsive behaviours). The tendency is only to report depressive symptoms, which of course tends to lead to a diagnosis of straight depression. It's a tough one for all concerned.
ReplyDeleteBut I have to say, in contrast to your experiences with the NHS, that they've been nothing less than fantastic with me. GPs are hit and miss (although I have had two absolute gems over the years), however every mental health specialist I've seen (a lot) have been amazing and have really done their utmost to see I'm given as much help as they can possibly throw at me. My current psychiatrist is so kind and caring, and has really gone out of her way to help me. God bless the NHS, because there's no way on this Earth I could afford to go private!
My advice to anyone seeking help beyond GP-prescribed antidepressants is to badger their GP into referring them to a specialist (eg consultant psychiatrist). Take in a list of your symptoms and print out a copy of the relevant NICE guidelines. Know your rights - your GP is not qualified to diagnose psychiatric disorders, and must refer you if there are symptoms which suggest one. It took me two tries (my first GP fobbed me off) but is well worth the persistence. Finally I am getting help to cope with these horrendous mood swings which have blighted my whole adult life!